Skip to content

The Legislative Quality Index: How We Score Every Draft Law Out of 100

Five published criteria weigh drafting quality, constitutional consistency, alignment with national strategy, social impact, and feasibility — inside the first Arab index of its kind.

Editorial Board·Published August 16, 2026·6 min read
رسم توليدي: ميزان يزن لفائف قوانين مقابل مؤشر جودة
صورة توليدية للإيضاح — ليست فوتوغرافيا

When a new draft law is tabled, the citizen's first question is: what will change in my life? The specialist asks: how sound is this text? The Legislative Quality Index answers both with a single published methodology.

Each draft receives a score out of 100 across five criteria: drafting quality (20%), constitutional and legal consistency (25%), alignment with national strategy (25%), social and economic impact (20%), and feasibility (10%). Scores are issued by an independent expert panel reviewing the text article by article.

The goal is not to hand out certificates but to ground public debate in criteria rather than impressions — turning legislative evaluation from scattered opinions into an accountable, discussable method.

Share

Related Stories

واجهة مبنى دار القضاء العالي في وسط القاهرة، بأعمدته الحجرية الكلاسيكية ورمزي ميزان العدالة المنحوتين على جانبي الواجهة وعلم مصر يعلوها
Legislation Platform

Egypt's New Criminal Procedure Code 174/2025 Takes Effect: What Has Actually Changed for Citizens?

After roughly seventy-six years, Egypt's old Criminal Procedure Code has been retired, and Law No. 174 of 2025 took effect with the start of the new judicial year. A measured look at what has actually changed: alternatives to pretrial detention, expanded from three to seven; detention periods and their ceilings; the presence of a lawyer; notification by modern means; and new safeguards for victims and witnesses.

October 18, 2026 · 8 min read

أربع حقن طبية بلاستيكية بأحجام مختلفة، إبرة كل منها داخل غطاء بلاستيكي شفاف، مرصوصة بشكل مائل متوازٍ على سطح قماشي أبيض، ولا يظهر على أسطوانتها سوى تدريج القياس بالمليلتر بلا اسم تجاري مقروء ولا دواء بداخلها.
The TruthFalse

“A Cold Shot Cures a Cold”: A False Claim, and What Trials Say About the “Power” of the Vein

“Forget the pills, take a shot and you'll be back on your feet” is advice that returns with the first chill of every year. We test two claims: that a “cold shot” cures a cold, and that an injection is inherently stronger than tablets. Verdict: false. The evidence lies in the mixture itself, in randomized trials comparing vein with mouth, and in an official Egyptian guide. The route of a medicine is the doctor's decision alone.

November 22, 2026 · 9 min read

الجزء السفلي من سخان مياه منزلي يعمل بالغاز مثبت على حائط داخلي فاتح اللون، تتوسطه لوحة تحكم معدنية بمفتاحين أحمرين ومفتاحَي ضبط مدوّرين ومؤشرين خلف زجاج أحدهما بتدريج رقمي للحرارة والضغط، ولوحة الاسم التجاري مطموسة فلا يظهر اسم ولا شعار لأي جهة صانعة.
Health News

The Silent Killer in the Bathroom: The Danger Is Not the Gas Heater but an Unventilated Room and Neglected Upkeep

With the first cold snap each year, Egyptian homes light their gas water heaters and shut their windows, turning a small bathroom into a room with no fresh air. Carbon monoxide has no colour, smell or taste, and its early symptoms are easily mistaken for a cold or fatigue. Here is what official sources say about the real cause of the danger, and the order of actions in the first minutes that could save a whole family.

November 21, 2026 · 8 min read